Systems

Sometimes Failure Is the Correct Output

When the same failure keeps repeating, it may not be a discipline problem. It may be the system working exactly as designed. Change the system, not just your effort.

By Mohanad Anan 4 min read

Labourers strain at the spokes of a great wooden water mill that will not turn, while a calm engineer kneels beside it with a lantern, inspecting a misaligned gear upstream.
In this essay · 4 sections
  1. 01 Repeated failure is data
  2. 02 My intermittent fasting mistake
  3. 03 The same thing happens in business
  4. 04 Stop fighting outputs. Inspect inputs.

We tend to think about failure in a very simple way:

I wanted outcome A. I got outcome B. Therefore, something went wrong.

And when the system involves ourselves, we often take it one step further:

Something went wrong because I wasn’t disciplined, motivated, skilled, or persistent enough.

But there is another possibility that is far more useful:

Sometimes failure isn’t a failure of the system. It’s the correct output of the system you’ve built.

The system may be functioning perfectly.

It’s just optimizing for an outcome you don’t want.

Repeated failure is data

If you try something once and fail, it might be bad luck.

If you try it twice and fail, perhaps you made a mistake.

But if you run essentially the same process over and over again and consistently get the same result, at some point you have to stop treating the result as an anomaly.

The repetition itself is information.

Instead of asking:

“Why can’t I make this work?”

Ask:

“What about this system makes this outcome predictable?”

That small change in perspective moves you from self-judgment to diagnosis.

And diagnosis gives you something you can actually work with.

A scholar at his desk lays a broken clay vessel beside a neat row of five identical broken vessels and studies them through a magnifying lens.
One failure is an accident. The same failure, lined up five times, is evidence.

My intermittent fasting mistake

I recently noticed this in my attempt to use intermittent fasting for weight loss.

My pattern was remarkably consistent.

I’d decide to start intermittent fasting. I’d stick to it for a day or two. Then I’d react badly to the restriction, abandon the protocol, and eventually try again.

And again.

And again.

My instinct was to interpret this as a discipline problem.

“Why can’t I just stick to it?”

But there was another interpretation.

Maybe failing at intermittent fasting was actually the predictable outcome of the conditions I was creating.

If the protocol repeatedly left me feeling poorly, made adherence unnecessarily difficult, and eventually caused me to abandon the diet, then demanding more discipline wasn’t necessarily the intelligent response.

The repeated failure was telling me something.

Perhaps intermittent fasting simply wasn’t a good protocol for me under those conditions.

That doesn’t mean intermittent fasting doesn’t work. It doesn’t even mean I could never make it work.

It means that this particular system, applied to me in this particular context, was repeatedly producing failure.

Once you see it that way, the question changes.

You stop asking:

“How do I become disciplined enough to tolerate this?”

And start asking:

“How could I design my diet so that adherence becomes the natural outcome?”

Maybe that means eating earlier. Maybe it means prioritizing highly satiating foods. Maybe it means spreading calories differently throughout the day.

The specific solution isn’t the important part.

The important part is recognizing that willpower should not be your first explanation for a repeatedly failing system.

The same thing happens in business

Imagine a company struggling to generate qualified sales opportunities.

Every month, management tells the sales team:

“We need more outreach.”

So the salespeople increase their activity.

More calls.

More emails.

More LinkedIn messages.

More follow-ups.

But pipeline quality remains terrible.

Management concludes that the salespeople aren’t working hard enough.

So targets increase again.

But suppose the real system looks like this:

Poorly defined ICP → generic messaging → low response rates → weak qualification → bad sales conversations → few deals.

In that system, poor sales performance isn’t surprising.

It’s the correct output.

You could put an extremely hardworking salesperson into that machine and still produce disappointing results.

The mistake is trying to improve the output by applying more force instead of examining the machinery producing it.

Fix the ICP.

Improve the offer.

Strengthen the messaging.

Improve qualification.

Give salespeople better leads.

Suddenly, the same amount of effort can produce a completely different result.

This is why repeated failure should trigger curiosity before self-criticism.

Workers at each arch of a long aqueduct scrub and polish the cups that catch its water, while far upstream the spring itself runs muddy.
Polishing the output changes little when the problem sits at the source.

Stop fighting outputs. Inspect inputs.

This mental model applies almost everywhere.

When you repeatedly procrastinate on a certain type of work, don’t immediately conclude that you’re lazy.

When employees repeatedly make the same mistake, don’t immediately conclude that they’re incompetent.

When customers repeatedly misunderstand your product, don’t immediately conclude that customers are stupid.

When a marketing campaign repeatedly attracts the wrong people, don’t immediately conclude that you need more budget.

Look upstream.

Ask what incentives, constraints, environments, processes, inputs, and feedback loops make the unwanted outcome likely.

Because systems don’t care about your intentions.

They respond to their conditions.

And sometimes what looks like failure from the perspective of your goal is actually perfectly rational behavior from the perspective of the system.

That gives us a useful rule:

When failure keeps repeating, stop treating it as an exception. It may be the system working exactly as designed. Change the system, not just your effort.

Sometimes you genuinely do need more discipline.

Sometimes you need more persistence.

Sometimes you simply need to try again.

But repeated failure deserves investigation.

Because the most dangerous response to a badly designed system is to keep blaming yourself—or everyone else inside it—and simply apply more force.

Before demanding a better output, make sure you’ve built a system capable of producing it.

Mohanad

Düsseldorf, 09 August 2026